Original Article |
|
| Hematological and Molecular Response Evaluation of CML Patients on Imatinib | |
| A Gupta*, K Prasad** | |
| Abstract Conclusion: Imatinib mesylate is highly effective in the treatment of chronic phase CML and so should be considered as the drug of first choice in CML. Molecular response evaluation after six months can predict the subsequent molecular response and can also be used as a surrogate monitor of the marrow cytogenetic response to imatinib therapy in CML. © |
INTRODUCTION |
Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
(CML) is a clonal myeloproliferative disorder of the pleuripotent hemopoietic
progenitor cell, characterized by excessive proliferation of marrow
granulocytes, erythroid precursors, megakaryocytes and connective tissue
forming cells. CML is a biphasic or triphasic disease.1 The disease
progresses through three distinct phases, chronic phase, accelerated
phase and blast crisis. |
Allogenic SCT is currently
the only curative therapy for CML and when feasible is the treatment
of choice. Today the goal of therapy is complete molecular remission
and cure. Imatinib (formerly STI-571), a tyrosine kinase inhibitor is a
revolution in the treatment of CML. |
The hematological remission rate
documented is more than 90% and the cytogenetic remission rate is around
60% with major cytogenetic remission rate of upto 30% in patients who
are in chronic phase of CML. However, the molecular remission, which
is the goal of present day therapy is not well documented. This study
besides evaluating hematological response aims to evaluate molecular
response to Imatinib in CML patients by the measurement of BCR-ABL
transcript level in blood using real time reverse transcriptase quantitative
polymerase chain reaction (RT Q-PCR). |
METHODS AND MATERIALS |
Sixteen patients, thirteen males
and three females in the age group of 26- 51 years who were diagnosed
as having Chronic Myeloid Leukemia, chronic phase, at Kasturba Medical
College Hospital, Attavar, Mangalore, during the period of two years
from January 2004 to January 2006 were started on Imatinib mesylate. All
the patients were diagnosed on the basis of clinical features, peripheral
blood smear (PBS) findings, Bone marrow aspiration (BMA) findings and
real time reverse transcriptase quantitative polymerase chain reaction
(RT Q-PCR). |
The dose of imatinib administered
was 400mg/day orally. They were followed closely over a period of 1
year using the following parameters: (1) monthly clinical examination,
(2) monthly peripheral blood smear examination, (3) RT Q-PCR for BCR-ABL
at the end of every 6 months. |
A patient was considered as having
responded at the hematological level2 if he/she achieved normal hemoglobin,
leucocyte and platelet indices within 3 months of starting treatment
with imatinib and the patient was free of all signs and symptoms. |
Real time RT Q-PCR provides an accurate,
sensitive and non-invasive method of measurement of residual leukemia.
BCR-ABL transcript quantification is expressed as percentage of control
gene. The sample showing amplification curve for both BCR-ABL target
gene and control gene are considered as positive for the test and reported
as % expression of BCR-ABL. The sample showing no amplification curve
for BCR-ABL target gene but shows amplification curve for control gene
is considered as negative for the test and reported as 0.0% expression.
In the absence of amplification curve for control gene test is reported
as invalid. |
The findings were analyzed after
the end of one-year therapy with imatinib to know the hematological
and molecular response as well as the side effects. |
RESULTS |
Thirteen (81.25%) out of sixteen
patients were males and three (18.75%) females (Table 1). The most
common symptoms with which the patients presented were weakness and
abdominal discomfort. Other symptoms were abdominal pain, fever and
weight loss (Table 1). All the patients, 16 (100%) had moderate to
massive splenomegaly at the time of presentation. Ten (62.5%) patients
had mild to moderate hepatomegaly at the time of presentation. Eleven
(68.75%) patients had pallor at the time of diagnosis (Table 1). All
the patients were diagnosed as having chronic phase CML on the basis of
PBS findings, BMA findings and real time RT Q-PCR. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
The most common side effects were
edema and arthralgia. Seven(43.75%) patients complained of arthralgia which
occurred mostly during the first two months of therapy and then gradually
subsided. |
DISCUSSION |
CML is a clonal disorder in which
cells of myeloid lineage undergo massive clonal expansion. The disease
progresses through three distinct phases, chronic phase, accelerated
phase and blast crises during which the leukemic clone progressively
loses its ability to differentiate. The underlying genetic abnormality
is a translocation described by the notation t(9;22)(q34;q11).3 This
results in the formation of Philadelphia chromosome (Ph) which is the
chromosomal abnormality seen in 95-100% of marrow cell metaphases of >90%
of CML patients. The molecular abnormality seen is the BCR-ABL gene.
The BCR-ABL fusion gene product is a 210 kDa protein which acts as
a constitutively activated tyrosine kinase. It subsequently activates
down stream kinases that prevent apoptosis and is responsible for abnormal
proliferation of cancer cells. Conventional treatment of CML has been
single agent therapy with either busulphan or hydroxyurea, which was
developed in 1960. But the disadvantages of these two historical drugs
were median survival of less than 3 years with a hematological remission
of 80% and no cytogenetic remission. The side effects of prolonged
treatment with these agents are skin pigmentation, infertility, and
interstitial fibrosis of lung. Allogenic SCT is currently the only
curative therapy for CML. When allogenic SCT is not feasible, IFN-a therapy
was the treatment of choice before imatinib become available. The BCR-ABL
tyrosine kinase is a well-validated therapeutic target in CML. All
of the transforming activities of BCR-ABL are dependent on its tyrosine
kinase activity. Thus, an inhibitor of the BCR-ABL kinase would be
predicted to be an effective and selective therapeutic agent for CML.
The treatment guidelines for patients with CML are undergoing substantial
change due to emerging evidence regarding the effectiveness of imatinib
mesylate. Imatinib induced hematological response in 82% of CML patients.4
The rate of major cytogenetic response was 24% (complete in 17%).4
Orally administered imatinib is an effective and well-tolerated treatment
for patients with CML in accelerated phase.4 Imatinib has substantial
activity and a favorable safety profile when used as a single agent
in patients with CML in blast crisis.5 Complete hematologic responses
typically occurred within four weeks after the initiation of therapy.6 |
All the patients were diagnosed as
having chronic phase CML and the dose of imatinib administered was
400mg/day. CML is more common in males. This is evidenced by the fact
that there were thirteen males and three females diagnosed and treated
in this study. The median age at diagnosis was 34 years. Splenomegaly
is a constant finding in CML as all the 16 patients had it at the time
of diagnosis. Hepatomegaly and pallor was also present in the majority
of patients at the time of diagnosis. Lymphadenopathy, however is not
a feature of chronic phase CML as evidenced by the fact that none of
the patients had it at the time of diagnosis. |
Fifteen (93.75%) patients achieved
CHR i.e. normal blood indices within a period of three months. Nine
(56.25%) patients achieved CHR within the first month of therapy with
imatinib. One (6.25%) patient who did not achieve complete hematological
response after three months of therapy did not achieve it even after
one year of therapy. The median time taken for CHR is one month. These
values suggest strongly that imatinib is very effective at the hematological
level of response in chronic phase CML. |
But the goal of present day therapy
of CML is complete molecular remission. Evaluation of molecular response
is a more sensitive method than cytogenetic response to find out residual
leukemia and also the response to the imatinib therapy. It also saves
the patient from pain due to multiple bone marrow aspirations and can
also predict the cytogenetic response, long term disease control, indicate
imatinib resistance or relapse if present, facilitate rationale patient
management, allow comparison of different imatinib based treatment
strategies. |
Six (37.5%) patients achieved CMR
in the first six months of imatinib therapy i.e. BCR-ABL/ABL ratio
equal to 0.0%. None of the patients who did not achieve complete molecular
response within first six months of therapy achieved it after one year
of therapy, however they showed slight improvement in their BCR-ABL/ABL
ratio. None of the patients who achieved complete molecular response
within first six months lost the response. The results are very encouraging
and show that Imatinib is highly effective at molecular level as compared
to earlier used drugs. |
The median BCR ABL/ABL value at the
end of the six months was 11%. The median BCR ABL/ABL value at the
end of the one year was 3.38%. Thus, we see that with imatinib therapy
the rate of molecular response is maximum during the first six months
and the probability and extent of molecular response decreases with
time if the patient does not respond in first six months. Thus molecular
response evaluation after six months can predict the subsequent molecular
response after one year. Several mechanisms of resistance to imatinib
have been identified from in intro studies of CML cell lines. For clinical
purposes two types of resistance to imatinib have been described7,
(1) upfront resistance to Imatinib which implies that patient fails
to respond to therapy, and (2) point mutation in BCR-ABL that prevented
imatinib from inhibiting it kinase activity or amplification of BCR-ABL
gene. |
Molecular response evaluation can
also predict the cytogenetic response as demonstrated by the study
done by Wang L et al,8 they found that in patients who had complete
cytogenetic remission (CCR) within six months, their BCR ABL / ABL
ratio was less than 0.08% at the end of the six months. In our study
there were six (37.5%) patients with BCR ABL / ABL value equal to 0.0%
after six months. So these six (37.5%) people can be considered to
be in CCR. In the study done by Wang L et al,8 patients who achieved
a partial cytogenetic response had their BCR ABL/ABL values between
0.08 and 10% after six months of treatment with imatinib. In our study
we have two (12.5%) patients who have BCR-ABL / ABL values between
0.08% and 10% after six months of therapy. These two (12.5%) patients
can be considered to have achieved a partial cytogenetic response in
6 months of therapy. However, at the end of one year there were six
(37.5%) patients with BCR-ABL/ABL values between 0.08% and 10%, so these
six (37.5%) patients can be considered to have achieved partial cytogenetic
response after one year of therapy. In the study done by Wang L et
al,8 cytogenetic non-responders had BCR ABL/ABL values more than 11%.
In our study we have eight (50%) patients with BCR-ABL / ABL values
more than 11% after six months of therapy and can be considered to
have had a minor or no cytogenetic response to imatinib after six months
of therapy. However at the end of one year we have only four (25%)
such patients, which can be considered as cytogenetic nonresponders.
Thus, real time RT Q-PCR can be used as a surrogate monitor of the
marrow cytogenetic response to imatinib therapy in CML. |
All the patients generally tolerated
imatinib therapy very well with minor side effects. The most common
side effects were edema and arthralgia. Seven (43.75%) patients complained
of arthralgia, which occurred mostly during the first two months of
therapy and then gradually subsided. Other side effects at the start
of therapy were vomiting, diarrhea, skin rash which were mild and subsided
in few days. |
CONCLUSION |
By this study we have concluded that
imatinib mesylate is highly effective in treating chronic phase CML
at the hematological and molecular level and so should be considered
as the drug of first choice in CML. Complete hematological response
was observed in fifteen (93.75%) patients within first three months
of treatment and was not lost during one year of follow up. Six (37.5%)
patients achieved complete molecular response in the first six months
of imatinib therapy as demonstrated by measurement of BCR ABL/ABL values
using real time RT Q-PCR, which is a highly sensitive method, used
to measure residual leukemia. The molecular response was also not lost
during the one year of follow up. Molecular response evaluation after
six months can predict the subsequent molecular response and can also
be used as a surrogate monitor of the marrow cytogenetic response to
imatinib therapy in CML. Molecular response evaluation can be used
as a parameter for long term evaluation of patients on imatinib. |
However, we still lack long term
follow up data on the efficacy of Imatinib in CML. Therefore, clinical
trials like this must continue for longer durations to find out the
durability of response and long term responses to imatinib in terms
of disease free survival and long term survival and also to find out
if it is of any advantage to use imatinib in combination with other
drugs or with other treatment modalities like allogenic stem cell transplant.
Imatinib mesylate has demonstrated the potential for development of
anti-cancer drugs based on the specific molecular abnormality present
in a human cancer. And so the future of cancer chemotherapy seems to revolve
around targeted molecular therapy and promises cure of various other
human cancers, which are at present untreatable. |
Acknowledgements |
The study was granted in part by
Indian Council of Medical Research under Short Term Research Studentship-2005.
We are thankful to the Indian Council of Medical Research. |
REFERENCES 1. Kantargian HM et al. Chronic leukemias - in Principles and Practice of Oncology. Devita, et al (2433-2445), 6th edition 2000. 2. Goldman JM et al. Clinical decisions for Chronic Myeloid Leukemia in the imatinib Era. Seminars in Hematology. 2003;40:98-103. 3. Oxford textbook of Oncology (1648-1658) 1995. 4. Talpaz Mosche et al. Imatinib induces durable hematologic and cytogenetic responses in patients with accelerated phase myeloid leukemia : Results of a phase 2 study. Blood 2002;99:192837. 5. Sawyers Charles L et al. Imatinib induces hematologic and cytogenetic responses in patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia in myeloid blast crises : results of a phase II study. Blood 2002;99:3530-9. 6. Drunker BJ, Talpaz M, Resta DJ, et al. Efficacy and safety of a specific inhibitor of the BCR-ABL tyrosine kinase in CML. N Engl J Med 2001;344:1031-7. 7. Sauyers et al. Chronic Myeloid Leukemia - Hematology 2001:87-98. |
![]() |