| Insulin Analogues in Modern Diabetes Management |
Premix Insulin: Initiation and Continuation Guidelines for Management of Diabetes in Primary Care Indian National Consensus Group* *Core Committee Members
Extended Core Committee Members Abstract: The role of insulin in providing good glycemic control and other systemic benefits is evidence based and irrefutable. In India a large proportion of patients with diabetes have to be cared for by the primary care physicians (PCPs). There exists some inhibition among PCPs regarding initiation and continuation of insulin therapy as it is perceived as complex, time consuming and need to have a team approach. Making the ideal (physiological) insulin therapy more acceptable to PCPs is a contemporary challenging need to contain diabetes in India. Premix insulin stands out as the a suitable & effective regimen to be used in primary care practice. Hence a national consensus group met with the objective of framing a guideline with simple and doable algorithm for using premix insulin therapy in primary care practice. This group recommended premix insulin may be used as a simple, safe, near physiological option and easy to start and stay regimen. Introduction India has the largest number of people with diabetes in the world. There were an estimated 42 million people with diabetes in 2007 and this number is predicted to rise to almost 70 million by 2025.1 Indians are more prone to develop diabetes and its complications at a younger age. Consequently burden of uncontrolled diabetes in India is high with more than two third of the treated patients not achieving optimal glycemic target. This to some extent can be attributed to low purchasing power and inadequate access to health care facilities in remote areas of our country.2,3,4 Type 2 diabetes is a progressive disease and is often diagnosed late. Patients are started on multiple oral anti-diabetics agents even when target glycemic control is not achieved. Although insulin therapy is most effective and suitable in most of these patients , it is usually started late, and more so intensified too slowly2,3. Delayed Insulin is on of the often cited reasons of poor glycaemic control among type 2 diabetics in our country2.This fundamentally stems from phsycian and patient inertia to initiate insulin on time. About large proportion of the people with diabetes in India are being treated by Primary care physicians (PCPs). PCPs have reluctance in using insulin for treating type 2 diabetes. They often perceive initiation and continuation of insulin therapy complex, time consuming and dependent upon a diabetes management team. Therefore, it is important to develop expertise in the use of regimens of insulin, that are less complicated yet enable patients to achieve target glycemic levels. The objective of this guideline is to empower the PCPs with simple and doable algorithm for starting and titrating premix insulin therapy. Needless to mention this will immensely help the nation in reducing the huge burden of mortality and morbidity due to uncontrolled hyperglycaemia .Basal Long acting Insulin is also an recommended option which is available and practiced in some parts of the world but cost remains an important barrier for its widespread routine use and is not discussed in this document. Indications Even though regular premix insulins is the most commonly used insulin in our country we do not yet have a clear elucidation of its availability in various formulations and its unique advantages. Indications for Insulin in Type 2 Diabetes
Insulin: An optimal choice Prandial insulin response is often blunted in people with type 2 diabetes6,7. Glycemic targets set by American College of Endocrinology (ACE), International Diabetes Federation (IDF), American Diabetes Association (ADA) and Association of Physicians of India (API) not only include preprandial glucose targets, but also postprandial glucose (PPG) goals (Table 1)8,9,10. Clinical and epidemiological studies have also correlated high PPG with increased cardiovascular risk11. Growing body of evidence also suggests that reducing postmeal plasma glucose excursions is as important,13 or perhaps most important for achieving HbA1c goals.9,13 Once-daily injection of long-acting insulin due to its inability to control post meal glucose excursions may not be the treatment option available to treat the insulin deficits and achieve glycemic targets especially in situations of post prandial hyperglycemia. However, premix insulin provides a combination of mealtime (rapid/short acting) and basal (intermediate/long acting) insulin in a preset ratio which may offer an advantage to offset the post prandial glycemic excursions. It consists of premix human insulin or premix insulin analogue in ratio of 30:70 and 50:50. Rapid/short-acting component (30% or 50%) covers mealtime glucose excursions, while intermediate/long-acting insulin (70% or 50%) augments background insulin levels. This may take care of fasting (FPG), prandial (PPG) & HbA1c with a single insulin14. Globally, the usage of premix insulin is quite high.in some parts of the world and may currently represents 38% of the world market in human insulin.15 Premix insulin is the preferred insulin because of The rationale for using Premix insulin therapy in India Basal insulin is a physiological option for diabetes used in the US and EU but cost is a major barrier for its routine use in PCP in India.The trasition of Basal to basal plus and basal bolus is complex and PCP may find it complex to use.The classical basal bolus regimen is the most ideal insulin regimen. However, in India, there are some practical difficulties in implementing it at the PCP level. It requires highly motivated patients and a significant amount of time to be spent for patient education and follow up. At the primary care level, there is absence of Team, Time, and Training. The concept of Diabetes Treatment Unit (DTU), carbohydrate count, self-mixing, judicious monitoring and adjustments is not feasible in our current primary care set up. Further, the patient may be reluctant to start insulin therapy with four injections per day if a classical basal bolus option is offered. Thus Premix insulin offers the advantage of being simple regimen to be adopted in primary care practice. It addresses both fasting and postprandial insulin requirement in a single injection.. It also avoids the disadvantages of traditional self mixing such as15: viz.need for proper sequencing,,Chances of dosing errors ,Chances of spillage in the vial base. Premix insulin is an option which may be used in all the stages of disease progression. It provides an option of easy intensification from once to twice, and sometimes even to thrice daily dosing to achieve control. Risk of hypoglycemia is less with premix insulins, and may be decreased with premix insulin analogues16,17. So this regimen may be scalable without any fear of less oglycemia. Moreover, a simple titration protocol involvesless and simple monitoring. Thus it provides an easy and practical approach of treating diabetes by PCPs whichmay increases compliance, and convenience for the patients. Premix Insulin:Is there published evidence base ? There is evidence that premix may be used as an option is situations like primary care .The INITIATE study showed that addition of premix insulin to Oral antidiabetic drugs (OADs) was more effective, than adding basal insulin for treatment of type 2 diabetes.18 The glycemic targets were attained in 66% of patients treated with premix insulin as compared to 40 % in the basal insulin arm. In another study comparing premix insulin therapy with basal bolus therapy, it was found to have effect equivalent to basal-bolus therapy in insulin naïve patients19..Designer Insulin Regimen in Clinical Practice has been investigated as a pilot multi-center Indian Study20. This study has depicted that both premix insulin analogues (two injections per day) and basal bolus analogue regimen (four injections per day) can be used as an equally effective way of initiating insulin therapy in type 2 diabetes. However, premix insulin analogue fared better than the basal-bolus regimen in lowering HbA1c (1.58 vs. 1.16%, p<0.05). Also 41% more patients in the premix insulin analogue group could achieve target HbA1c <7% at the end of study. Patient’s adherence & compliance to the therapy was better with premixed insulin group.However large multicenter and global GCP trials addressing this issue are lacking.The “4T” trial did address this issue and came with conflicting results. Various Guidelines for the Use of Premix Insulin American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists (AACE) guidelines suggest premix insulin is indicated for patients with HbA1c above 8.0%8. International Diabetes Federation (IDF) suggests twice-daily premix insulin is recommended particularly for patients with elevated HbA1c, which is the case scenario in our country.21 ICMR diabetes treatment guideline recommends use of premix insulin twice a day as a choice for multiple injection therapy.22 NICE type 2 diabetes treatment guideline 200823 for type 2 diabetes considers twice-daily biphasic human insulin (pre-mix) regimens when HbA1c is elevated above 9.0 % though once-daily regimen may be an option when initiating this therapy. It suggests to consider the option of pre-mixed preparations of insulin analogues rather than pre-mixed human insulin preparations when • immediate injection before a meal is preferred, or Despite of limitations due to compliance and convinenace in primary care setting premix insulin still option which merits use in primary care. Combination therapy - OAD with Premix Insulin Use of insulin in combination with OADs is one of the main stay of type 2 diabetes therapy. Premix insulin can be combined with insulin sensitizers and secretagogues when initiated once daily, nonetheless, OADs can be continued with twice and thrice daily premix insulin therapy also.24,25 Metformin / TZDs with Premix insulin: Addition of metformin to premix insulin is preferred to thiazolidinediones (TZDs) in patients not reaching the target. Metformin prevents weight gain and also reduces the dose requirement of insulin.26,27 TZDs also reduce the dose requirement of premix insulin but causes weight gain.28 Studies have shown better achievement of glycemic targets with this combination. Therefore, premix insulin can be combined with Metformin or TZDs. The order in which these two sensitizers are added to insulin treatment is important; if metformin is added before a thiazolidinedione, weight gain may be avoided.29 Secretagogues with premix insulin It is also recommended that premix may be combined with secretagogues. If a patient is already on sulfonylurea, it should be continued while adding premix insulin to the therapy. The effect of secretagogues is not class specific.26,29 It has been observed that 30 to 40% of patients can achieve the glycemic targets by combination of once daily premix insulin with OADs.25,26 However, the therapy needs to be intensified with the decline of ß-cell function (= insulin secretion) as disease progresses. In this case premix insulin should be scaled up to twice and thrice daily with or without one or multiple class of OADs. Initiation and titration of Premix insulin Premix insulin can be started once daily with 10 U either in the morning (AM), if night-time glucose is high or in the night (PM), if the morning glucose is high. If the total insulin dose exceeds 20 U, then premix insulin can be given twice daily, before breakfast and before dinner (AM & PM), distributed as two third in morning and one third in evening. However, premix analogues should be distributed in two equal halves in morning and evening when single dose exceeds 30 units. Also premix insulin may be started twice daily in case of patients with higher HbA1c, or if blood glucose control is suboptimal.
The “nuts and bolts” of achieving control with Premix insulin The usual initiating dose is about 10 units of premix insulin either morning (AM) or night (PM). The dose can be titrated as given below (Table 2). The blood sugar levels need to be monitored every week and the dose titrated. The simple principle of “starting low and scaling slow” must be applied. Second dose to be given if Simple monitoring procedure while on Premix insulin Premix insulin can be given once daily before breakfast or dinner. Then it can be intensified to twice or thrice daily. Night (PM) or morning (AM) dose needs to be titrated based upon pre-breakfast or pre-dinner blood glucose respectively. Dosage adjustments based on pre-meal blood glucose should be done as depicted in the table 2.Titration should be done at regular interval (at least weekly) until glycemic goals are achieved. Premix Human Insulin and Premix Insulin Analogue – A comparative evaluation Premixed insulin analogues contain a fixed proportion of soluble, rapid-acting insulin analogue along with protaminated analogue like human premix insulin. Analogue premixes have more physiological pharmacokinetic and therapeutically more desirable pharmacodynamic profiles than premixed human insulin.30 Consequently, postprandial glycaemic control is better with premixed insulin analogues than with premixed human insulin. Minor and major hypoglycaemia appears to be rare with these modern insulins.15,17 The premixed insulin analogues, also allow flexibility relative to meal timing, thus improving adherence, compliance and quality of life compared with premixed human insulin.31 Overall, the evidence for its safety and effectiveness suggests that premixed insulin analogues are cost effective and have useful advantages (Table 3) over premixed human insulin for the treatment of type 2 diabetes. Switching from premix human insulin to premix Insulin analogue should be done on unit for unit basis. Premix insulin in special situations a. Pregnancy There is adequate evidence and experience that the Premix human insulin can be used in pre-gestational and gestational diabetes in our country. These insulins are safe and effective with favourable outcomes. For women with postprandial hyperglycemia on premixed human insulin, recommending premix insulin analogue though appears rational, it has not yet received a formal approval by Indian regulators. Hence use of premix insulin analogues in pregnancy should be based on individual patients need and physicians experience. b. Adolescents Indications for Referral Availability of Insulin in delivery devices: Any successful antidiabetic therapy must involve recognition of the lifestyle and quality-of-life issues that the patient encounters in the daily management of this disease. The perceived patient barriers of insulin therapy include the psychological discomfort of self-injection, fear of gaining weight, and fear of hypoglycemia.33 Insulin is normally delivered from syringes, necessitating accuracy of insulin doses drawn up from insulin vials under suitably hygienic conditions. Also it involves equipment to carry and store, which might be inconvenient for patients who travel or are physically active.34 Modern pen injector devices obviate most of these problems and offer a convenient and safe means of carrying around injection equipment. A study comparing a pen with a conventional syringe and vial found that setting and drawing up the dose of insulin was significantly easier for patients using the pen (p=0.0490).35 The insulin injection devices have easy-to-read dial, large button for injection and audible clicks for units injected, Also the needles used with these devices are fine (31G) which cause significantly less pain than with syringes and vials (p=0.0018).35 Even patients with motor dysfunction and/or visual problems have found device more convenient to the vial and syringe. In all studies comparing pens with conventional syringes more patients stated a preference for the pens over the conventional syringe and vial.36,37 Advantages of insulin pen devices over conventional insulin syringes35-38 • More convenient insulin delivery Storage and administration of Premix Insulin It is ideal to keep insulin at 2°C - 8°C in a refrigerator (not too near the freezer compartment), the insulin vial or pen devices should never freeze. In absence of this facility, the vial/pen device/penfills may be kept in a cool place (eg. Near a pitcher in kitchen), away from heat and direct sunlight. However, such a vial or delivery device has to be used within a period of 4 weeks. The necessity of resuspending the premix insulin preparation immediately before use is to be stressed to the patient. The resuspended liquid must appear uniformly white and cloudy. Excess agitation should be avoided to prevent loss of potency, clumping, frosting or precipitation. Conclusion Premix insulins are a reasonalble option which is effective in all the stages and offers unique advantage of simplicity and convenience. These regimens may be used throughout the course of the disease. Availability of these insulins in pens has reduced the time needed to learn injection technique . There may be a lower index of intrusion into patient’s personal life with premix regimen option compared to conventional basal bolus which may have s a positive impact on the quality of life. Acknowledgement, Methodology of the Preperation and Conflict of Interest This document was prepared with the help of s 27 diabetologist, physician and endocrinologists who took the challenge of disseminating this information among the PCPs and physicians in a structured format and developed this guideline. This group of 27 experts (Core committee and extended core committee members) discussed and defined the problem of insulin usage in primary care. Evidences in this regard were searched systematically and critically appraised. A recommendation was made based on these evidences and the clinical experience. A primary draft was prepared. This was circulated among the committee members and edited for consistency of style and terminology. Then the draft was sent to 250 diabetologist and physicians across the country for their perusal and suggestions. These suggestions were incorporated to the maximum extent and final draft was prepared. This development of guideline is supported by an unrestricted educational grant from Novo Nordisk India Pvt Ltd. References
|